navigation logo
Skip to Main Content
  • MENUS
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • CATERING
  • Twitter pageFacebook page
  • GIFT CARDS
  • ORDER MERCH
  • ORDER FOOD
  • JOBS
Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, West Allis logo
  • Twitter pageFacebook page
  • MENUS
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • ORDER MERCH
  • ORDER FOOD
  • JOBS

Our Menu

Main MenuNut Butters | Jams | Jellies

PBJ Sandwiches

Toppings: Bacon, Ham, Mallow Creme, Marshmallows, Nutella, Jalapeños, Chocolate Sauce, Honey, Caramel Sauce, Pickles, Sliced Fruit (Strawberry, Apple, Bananas, Sriracha Sauce, Cream Cheese, and more!

Strawberry Lovers photo

Strawberry Lovers

$6.50
A thick layer of our fresh, crunchy, honey roasted peanut butter, spread with a layer of strawberry jam and topped with fresh sliced strawberries.
The King photo

The King

$6.75
A grilled sandwich with a layer of our all-natural or honey roasted peanut butter combined with sliced bananas and honey. Treat yourself and try it with bacon.
PB Banana photo

PB Banana

$6.50
All-natural peanut butter with a layer of Nutella and topped with sliced bananas.
Grilled Cheese & Jelly photo

Grilled Cheese & Jelly

$6.25
Your choice of American or sharp cheddar cheese and any of our craft jams or jellies, all melted between your choice of bread.
The Big Apple photo

The Big Apple

$6.25
The PBJD's own freshly ground peanut butter is smothered with our chunky apple jam. Topped with freshly diced apples.
Double Decker photo

Double Decker

$6.75
Two layers of our freshly ground peanut butter and your choice of jam or jelly between three slices of toast.
Crunch & Punch photo

Crunch & Punch

$5.95
PBJD's crunchy peanut butter paired with a zesty layer of raspberry jalapeno jam.
You're Killin' Me Smalls photo

You're Killin' Me Smalls

$6.50
Dark chocolate peanut butter crushed Graham Crackers and drizzled with mallow creme.
Peanut Butter & Yeli photo

Peanut Butter & Yeli

$7.50
1/4 lb hot dog on a hoagie bun, with natural peanut butter, jalapeño jelly, jalapeño relish and bacon.
Build Your Own PBJ photo

Build Your Own PBJ

$5.95
Go nuts and pick your bread, your nut butter, and your jam or jelly!
Bagel PB photo

Bagel PB

$5.50
A sliced, toasted bagel topped with peanut butter, drizzled with honey, and sprinkled with cinnamon.
Yummy Cashew photo

Yummy Cashew

$7.50
PBJD's freshly ground cashew butter served with a jam, jelly, or fruit spread of your choice.
Almond Delight photo

Almond Delight

$7.50
PBJD's freshly ground almond butter served with a jam, jelly, or fruit spread of your choice.
Peanut Butter Oreo photo

Peanut Butter Oreo

$6.50
Dark chocolate peanut butter, crumbled Oreo cookies, and mallow creme fused together on the grill.
PBJ Quesadilla photo

PBJ Quesadilla

$5.95
A flour tortilla wrapped with your choice of peanut butter, jams, and fresh fruit. Grilled to perfection.

Soups

Soups

Fresh soups daily from The Soup Market.

Drinks

Coffee photo

Coffee

PBJ Deli locally roasted coffee served fresh daily.
Milkshakes photo

Milkshakes

$4.75/Vanilla
$4.75/Chocolate
Signature Milkshakes
PBJ Deli Floats photo

PBJ Deli Floats

Root Beer - Old School Ice Cream Floats featuring our signature PBJ Deli Soda Pops

Nut Butters

Natural Peanut Butter photo

Natural Peanut Butter

$5.99/1lb
Honey Roasted Peanut Butter photo

Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

$6.99/1lb
Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate photo

Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate

$6.99/1lb
Almond Butter photo

Almond Butter

$12.99/1lb
Cashew Butter photo

Cashew Butter

$12.99/1lb

Jams

Apricot

Apricot Peach

Blackberry photo

Blackberry

Seedless Blackberry

Blueberry photo

Blueberry

Blueberry Rhubarb

Blue Blazes

Boysenberry

Cherry

Cherry Berry

Cherry Jalapeño

Cherry Amaretto

Cherry Blueberry

Cherry Raspberry

Cinnamon Pear

Dark Sweet Cherry

Double Cherry

Double Raspberry

Dutch Apple photo

Dutch Apple

F.R.O.G.

Gooseberry photo

Gooseberry

Guava

Hot Pepper

Hot Peach Pepper

Hot Raspberry

Jalapeño Pepper

Kiwi

Loganberry photo

Loganberry

Mango

Orange Marmalade photo

Orange Marmalade

Orange Cherry Marmalade

Orange Pineapple

Passion Fruit

Peach photo

Peach

Peach Amaretto

Peach Blueberry

Peach Jalapeño

Peach Rhubarb

Pear Apple Chai

Pineapple

Purple Plum photo

Purple Plum

Red Raspberry

Red Raspberry Jalapeño

Red Raspberry Rhubarb photo

Red Raspberry Rhubarb

Rhubarb photo

Rhubarb

Seedless Boysenberry

Seedless Red Raspberry

Seedless Strawberry

Strawberry photo

Strawberry

Strawberry Kiwi

Strawberry Rhubarb photo

Strawberry Rhubarb

Sweet Pepper

Tomato photo

Tomato

Very Berry

Watermelon

Jellies

Apple Cinnamon photo

Apple Cinnamon

Blackberry photo

Blackberry

Black Currant

Blueberry

Boysenberry photo

Boysenberry

Cherry

Cranberry photo

Cranberry

Dandelion

Elderberry photo

Elderberry

Grape

Mint

Plum

Quince

Red Currant photo

Red Currant

Red Raspberry photo

Red Raspberry

Sassafras

Strawberry

Fruit Butters

Apple Butter photo

Apple Butter

Apple Blueberry Butter

Apple Cherry Butter

Apricot Butter

Blueberry Butter

Cherry Butter

Peach Butter

Pear Butter

Plum Butter

Pumpkin Butter

Sugarless Jams

No Granulated Sugars Added

Apricot

Blackberry

Seedless Blackberry

Blueberry

Cherry

Peach

Red Raspberry

Seedless Red Raspberry

Strawberry

Strawberry Rhubarb

  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs