Our Menu
PBJ Sandwiches
Toppings: Bacon, Ham, Mallow Creme, Marshmallows, Nutella, Jalapeños, Chocolate Sauce, Honey, Caramel Sauce, Pickles, Sliced Fruit (Strawberry, Apple, Bananas, Sriracha Sauce, Cream Cheese, and more!
![Strawberry Lovers photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Strawberry Lovers
$6.50
A thick layer of our fresh, crunchy, honey roasted peanut butter, spread with a layer of strawberry jam and topped with fresh sliced strawberries.
![The King photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
The King
$6.75
A grilled sandwich with a layer of our all-natural or honey roasted peanut butter combined with sliced bananas and honey. Treat yourself and try it with bacon.
![PB Banana photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
PB Banana
$6.50
All-natural peanut butter with a layer of Nutella and topped with sliced bananas.
![Grilled Cheese & Jelly photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Grilled Cheese & Jelly
$6.25
Your choice of American or sharp cheddar cheese and any of our craft jams or jellies, all melted between your choice of bread.
![The Big Apple photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
The Big Apple
$6.25
The PBJD's own freshly ground peanut butter is smothered with our chunky apple jam. Topped with freshly diced apples.
![Double Decker photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Double Decker
$6.75
Two layers of our freshly ground peanut butter and your choice of jam or jelly between three slices of toast.
![Crunch & Punch photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Crunch & Punch
$5.95
PBJD's crunchy peanut butter paired with a zesty layer of raspberry jalapeno jam.
![You're Killin' Me Smalls photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
You're Killin' Me Smalls
$6.50
Dark chocolate peanut butter crushed Graham Crackers and drizzled with mallow creme.
![Peanut Butter & Yeli photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Peanut Butter & Yeli
$7.50
1/4 lb hot dog on a hoagie bun, with natural peanut butter, jalapeño jelly, jalapeño relish and bacon.
![Build Your Own PBJ photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Build Your Own PBJ
$5.95
Go nuts and pick your bread, your nut butter, and your jam or jelly!
![Bagel PB photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Bagel PB
$5.50
A sliced, toasted bagel topped with peanut butter, drizzled with honey, and sprinkled with cinnamon.
![Yummy Cashew photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Yummy Cashew
$7.50
PBJD's freshly ground cashew butter served with a jam, jelly, or fruit spread of your choice.
![Almond Delight photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Almond Delight
$7.50
PBJD's freshly ground almond butter served with a jam, jelly, or fruit spread of your choice.
![Peanut Butter Oreo photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Peanut Butter Oreo
$6.50
Dark chocolate peanut butter, crumbled Oreo cookies, and mallow creme fused together on the grill.
![PBJ Quesadilla photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
PBJ Quesadilla
$5.95
A flour tortilla wrapped with your choice of peanut butter, jams, and fresh fruit. Grilled to perfection.
Soups
Soups
Fresh soups daily from The Soup Market.
Drinks
![Coffee photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Coffee
PBJ Deli locally roasted coffee served fresh daily.
![Milkshakes photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Milkshakes
$4.75/Vanilla
$4.75/Chocolate
Signature Milkshakes
![PBJ Deli Floats photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
PBJ Deli Floats
Root Beer - Old School Ice Cream Floats featuring our signature PBJ Deli Soda Pops
Nut Butters
![Natural Peanut Butter photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Natural Peanut Butter
$5.99/1lb
![Honey Roasted Peanut Butter photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Honey Roasted Peanut Butter
$6.99/1lb
![Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate
$6.99/1lb
![Almond Butter photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Almond Butter
$12.99/1lb
![Cashew Butter photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Cashew Butter
$12.99/1lb
Jams
Apricot
Apricot Peach
![Blackberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Blackberry
Seedless Blackberry
![Blueberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Blueberry
Blueberry Rhubarb
Blue Blazes
Boysenberry
Cherry
Cherry Berry
Cherry Jalapeño
Cherry Amaretto
Cherry Blueberry
Cherry Raspberry
Cinnamon Pear
Dark Sweet Cherry
Double Cherry
Double Raspberry
![Dutch Apple photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Dutch Apple
F.R.O.G.
![Gooseberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Gooseberry
Guava
Hot Pepper
Hot Peach Pepper
Hot Raspberry
Jalapeño Pepper
Kiwi
![Loganberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Loganberry
Mango
![Orange Marmalade photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Orange Marmalade
Orange Cherry Marmalade
Orange Pineapple
Passion Fruit
![Peach photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Peach
Peach Amaretto
Peach Blueberry
Peach Jalapeño
Peach Rhubarb
Pear Apple Chai
Pineapple
![Purple Plum photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Purple Plum
Red Raspberry
Red Raspberry Jalapeño
![Red Raspberry Rhubarb photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Red Raspberry Rhubarb
![Rhubarb photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Rhubarb
Seedless Boysenberry
Seedless Red Raspberry
Seedless Strawberry
![Strawberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Strawberry
Strawberry Kiwi
![Strawberry Rhubarb photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Strawberry Rhubarb
Sweet Pepper
![Tomato photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Tomato
Very Berry
Watermelon
Jellies
![Apple Cinnamon photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Apple Cinnamon
![Blackberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Blackberry
Black Currant
Blueberry
![Boysenberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Boysenberry
Cherry
![Cranberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Cranberry
Dandelion
![Elderberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Elderberry
Grape
Mint
Plum
Quince
![Red Currant photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Red Currant
![Red Raspberry photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Red Raspberry
Sassafras
Strawberry
Fruit Butters
![Apple Butter photo](https://static.spotapps.co/web/placeholder.png)
Apple Butter
Apple Blueberry Butter
Apple Cherry Butter
Apricot Butter
Blueberry Butter
Cherry Butter
Peach Butter
Pear Butter
Plum Butter
Pumpkin Butter
Sugarless Jams
No Granulated Sugars Added