Wisconsin's only shop dedicated to serving America's favorite sandwich. Located in the Six Points neighborhood of West Allis, the PBJ Deli specializes in classic and gourmet peanut butter & jelly sandwiches as well as other specialty foods and treats that feature our Peanut Butter & Jelly combinations!
Our focus is on fresh, locally made peanut butter spreads, jellies, jams, and bread. All of our nut butter is made every day in our shop. Our jams & jellies are packed with fruit and are made at local jelly farms and bread is brought in fresh, from local bakeries. All of our fresh nut butter, jams, and jellies are for sale to enjoy at home.
Every day in our shop, we offer the world's largest selection of freshly ground nut butter and regionally made craft jams, jellies, and fruit butter spreads. If you can't make it to us, you can still have our products delivered right to your door.
Order now
The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli offers a cool, one-of-a-kind, affordable, and casual space that is perfect for cocktail parties, business meetings, wedding rehearsal dinners, bridal showers, birthday parties, retirement parties, networking events, and holiday parties.
If you are looking to make your next event one to remember, the PBJD team can come to your location and set up and staff a Peanut Butter and Jelly bar. With our choices of plain, toasted, or grilled bread, our variety of 10 house-made peanut butter, and 100 locally made, fruit-packed jellies and jams.
Such a fun place! We went their for our first time last weekend and enjoyed all aspects of our pb&j experience. The food is interesting and delicious, the staff is extremely pleasant, and the atmosphere is cute great! We all had different variations of The King, Grilled Cheese & Jelly, and Crunch & Punch. The chicken enchilada soup was super yummy.
If you're craving a PP&J there's simply no other place to go. All kinds of peanut butter, jelly and other toppings to have whatever kind of sandwich you're looking for. A really cute shop with modern and cozy decorations. Plus the customer service was top notch. Go support a small unique local business!
The best peanut butter I've EVER had!!! This place is such a gem. Walk up to the counter to order - pick your pb and jam (they provide you with a crazy long list!) Or you can order some special combinations and add fruit, etc. I loved the PB SO MUCH that I bought one to take home ...& the chocolate pb :) I highly recommend you give this place a try!
I was looking for a quick snack that wasn't a fast food chain, and happened to find PB&JD. I am so glad I did, as it was one of the best PB&J's I've ever had. The menu is great and I'll definitely be back to explore more. The customer service was fantastic as well. Their own PB and Jelly jars to go is also a plus! Make sure you check this place out.
Absolutely delicious. What a fantastic place and what a great concept. Trust me when I say one sandwich will definitely fill you up. Great staff, great service, great choices. This is a place that you could stop in numerous times and always enjoy a new sandwich. So many choices. Be sure to check them out.
